This story took place during my Junior College years, when I
was the head of organizing committee for the freshman orientation camp. Apart
from ensuring a fun-filled orientation, safety was not compromised and thus I had
a sub- committee responsible for safety.
Back then there was this orientation leader; Mindy, whose
sporty appearance, cheerful character and her highly responsible attitude
greatly attracted many of the guys. During the orientation, there was an
unfortunate accident whereby one of Mindy’s freshmen injures his ankle during
the games. My head of safety, Sarah, immediately attended to the freshmen,
subsequently bringing him to the PE
room for further inspection. An hour later the freshmen joined the rest of his
Orientation Group (OG) for non-physical activities. However, after dinner, the injured freshman was
complaining of unbearable pain in his injured ankle. Subsequently the freshman
was sent to the nearest hospital for checkups.
During the camp de-
brief, I was informed that the freshman actually had suffered a minor fracture
in his ankle. Mindy voiced out during the de- brief, mentioning that the
committee in charge of safety could have actually managed the aforementioned
situation better instead of putting the freshman at greater risk by letting him
stayed on. Other leaders who were also present at the de- brief nodded in
agreement. Following that, Sarah broke down and ran out of the room.
Unknown to them, on
that day Sarah had actually insisted the freshman to be sent to hospital
immediately after the accident, but the freshman insisted that the injury was
bearable and simple bandaging will suffice. After much assurance by the
freshman that he was fine, Sarah then relented and allowed him to return to his
OG.
So how do you think
both Mindy and Sarah could have handled the situation better? What kind of
approach should Mindy has taken instead? If they had communicated better, would the ending be less awkward?

Hi Weipin!
ReplyDeleteI feel that Mindy should have handled the situation in a better manner. Perhaps she could have talked to Sarah about it beforehand to understand the circumstance that Sarah was in, before speaking about it in front of everyone during the debrief as that could have made Sarah feel targeted, upset, embarrassed or wronged as the other leaders may have had the impression that it was Sarah's fault that it happened. At the same time, perhaps Sarah could have also explained the situation when Mindy brought it up instead of avoiding the problem because running away could have caused tension or awkwardness among the other people who were present during the debrief! All in all, I feel that when something like that happens, it is always crucial to seek accurate information or talk to the person individually instead of pointing the mistake out in front of everyone as that could cause that person distress.
Lastly, your post was written in a very clear, it was written in a detailed manner and the content is indeed enlightening; it has also given me a clearer picture of what to do when in a situation like this to avoid misunderstandings and conflicts.
Adeline Ng
Hello Weipin! It was a clear description and gave some interesting observations of how different people react to conflict. By the way good job with the music, it is pretty soothing hahah!
ReplyDeleteThe tone in which Mindy broached the subject was critical. If it had been very accusatory and derogatory then Sarah's dramatic exit is quite justifiable. But if Mindy had respectfully brought up the situation, it would have been an over-reaction on Sarah's part. Mindy could have asked Sarah what had happened before jumping to conclusions. Also in evaluating sessions, it would always be appropriate to mention personal shortcomings before evaluating others, just as a respectful formality. Mindy could have first mentioned that she was not alert and did not pay close enough attention to the freshman’s condition during the non-physical activities. So that when she evaluates others next, it cushions the criticism slightly. To avoid awkwardness and feelings of injustice, no particular person should feel like they are being singled out. Maybe someone should have stepped in to intervene when the evaluations seemed to be heading in that direction. Perhaps Mindy's outgoing personality intimidated Sarah, but Sarah should have explained herself instead of letting her emotions overwhelm her.
Stefanie
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Wei Pin! I think this story of yours is very relatable to anyone who has been in a camp committee before.
ReplyDeleteRegarding your story, I would first like to say this. If Sarah was a professional paramedic, the would be liable for her mistake and be charged accordingly. In a professional setting, the injured patient would have no authority to go against or reject medical judgement.
But let's be quite frank about this. Sarah's not a professional. It might have been wrong of her to allow the freshmen to return to the camp, but we can tell that she treats her job very seriously given her quick response time she took to attend to the injury.
I feel that Mindy should have approached Sarah in a private setting so as to clarify the situation. It would also show that she respects Sarah's efforts as the safety manager and putting her on the spot during a mass de-brief is not nice.
If I were Sarah I would have trusted my judgement and rejected the freshmen's plea to continue in the camp.
Jonathan Koh